Environment Canada officials told MPs the decision to stop work on banning exports of thermal coal was made at the political level.
The Story
Environment Canada officials told members of the House of Commons environment committee that the decision to stop the department’s work on banning exports of thermal coal came from the political level.
Assistant deputy minister Megan Nichols, from Environment Canada’s environmental protection branch, told MPs she could not say why Liberals made the call, but said the department is committed to explaining the decision in its official response to a recent report by Canada’s environment commissioner.
The commissioner’s October report found Environment Canada abandoned its work to end thermal coal exports without notifying the public and without any record of being directed to do so.
Nichols said there was no written record of the direction to stop the work, saying it was communicated through officials up to the political level.
"It was communicated to me via the deputy minister at the time. But then that was communicated to the deputy minister from the political level. So I don't know who it came from at that point," Nichols told the committee.
She said Environment Canada was told to reallocate resources to other priorities after the department had shared its analysis.
Nichols said, "We were told to reallocate our resources to other priorities. We had shared our analysis. So I can only conclude that the government considered our analysis and made the decision on that basis."
Nichols said Environment Canada’s analysis concluded that even if Canada stopped exporting thermal coal, it would not make much difference in lowering overall global emissions because Canada’s exports account for about two per cent of global thermal coal supply.
She also said the department considered enforcement challenges, including "trade risks," and pointed to Canada’s trade agreements with partners such as the United States.
"That included our trade agreements with partners such as the (United States) that rely on Canada to export a great deal of their thermal coal," Nichols said.
The officials said that in 2025, 61 per cent of thermal coal shipped from Canadian ports came from the United States, and that American mines generally send the coal by train to shipping terminals in British Columbia because regulations in the U.S. make it difficult to build Pacific coast export infrastructure.
Nichols said she was not aware of any pressure from the U.S. government to discourage Canada from following through with its export-ban commitment.
She told MPs Environment Canada assessed the potential impact on free-trade obligations, saying, "We, of course, did our due diligence and doing the analysis of if we were to cease exporting U.S. thermal coal through our terminals, what would that mean in terms of our free trade obligations with the U.S.," and that "of course, that was a consideration that we took."
The commissioner’s report found Environment Canada worked to find a way to enforce the ban for three years, but that the work stopped in November 2024 after lobbying from the coal industry.
It also found enforcement work was scaled down before Ottawa ultimately gave up on it.
The audit reported that between October 2021 and February 2024, Environment Canada officials attempted to use existing laws to enforce the export ban, including by treating thermal coal as a toxic substance, similar to approaches Ottawa has taken with single-use plastics.
By February 2024, the audit said officials shifted to considering non-regulatory approaches, described as "voluntary measures," and Environment Canada officials later told the Office of the Auditor General that these voluntary measures included exploring agreements that are voluntarily committed or agreed to for terminal facilities to end thermal coal exports.
The Office of the Auditor General said in a statement that decisions related to the shift were not consistently supported by documented senior management approvals.
Officials said the government has so far declined to indicate whether it remains committed to banning thermal coal exports, noting only that it is considering next steps, and that the decision to stop the work was not formalized until August 2025 when the federal government sought cost-saving measures.
The hearing also addressed criticism that Ottawa did not tell the public, or even Global Affairs Canada, that Environment Canada had been pursuing information about trade risks while developing the ban.
← More stories