A witness told a House of Commons ethics committee Monday that surveillance pricing could lead some grocery shoppers to pay more based on inferred purchasing habits.
The Story
People with religious or health-based food restrictions could face higher grocery prices under algorithmic or “surveillance” pricing, an expert told MPs at a parliamentary committee Monday in Ottawa.
Sarah-Louise Ruder, an adjunct professor at the University of the Fraser Valley’s food and agriculture institute, said the impact has been observed in the United States and can occur when prices are tied to a shopper’s inferred willingness to pay.
Ruder was answering a question from Liberal MP Fares Al Soud, who described how some consumers may have fewer alternatives because of shopping habits that could be inferred, such as avoiding pork or alcohol, and said similar issues can apply for Hindu, Jewish and celiac customers.
Ruder replied that it is “absolutely” possible for people who have essentials or frequent purchases to be charged more because their purchasing patterns suggest limited alternatives.
She said electronic shelf labels can make algorithmic price changes possible based on other factors—for example, increasing the price of coffee in the morning or making popsicles more expensive on a hot day.
Ruder said Canadian grocers have told the committee they will not use in-store electronic shelf labels for surveillance or personalized pricing, adding that doing so “would be challenging” and could require additional sources of data collection, including video feeds throughout aisles.
The House of Commons ethics committee is studying the use of artificial intelligence in algorithmic pricing, which is also referred to as surveillance pricing.
Renjie Butalid, co-founder of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute, said there needs to be a clear distinction between pricing based on market conditions and surveillance pricing that uses personal information to determine individualized charges.
Butalid described a scenario in which a parent urgently buying baby formula may have few alternatives, and a surveillance pricing system could use that to charge more.
He recommended “a general prohibition on surveillance pricing where businesses use personal information, behavioral data, or inferences about individual consumers to determine individualized prices.”
In an earlier meeting, the committee heard from Keldon Bester, the executive director of the Canadian Anti-Monopoly Project, who said research in the United States found Instacart charged some customers as much as 23 per cent more than others.
That research, cited by the committee earlier, was attributed to Consumer Reports and Groundwork Collaborative, based on algorithmic pricing experiments by Instacart; a spokesperson for Instacart told the committee the experiments ended a year ago and did not involve personalized or surveillance pricing, and that the company has committed to not using surveillance pricing.
Butalid said it is often unclear when Canadians are being subjected to algorithmic pricing, adding that as these strategies become cheaper and easier to apply, algorithmic pricing could become more widespread.
The committee also heard testimony from Emily Osborne, a policy research associate at the Canadian Shield Institute for Public Policy, who said surveillance pricing is a “black box” for customers.
Osborne told MPs that consumers do not know when they are seeing different prices or why, and that volatility can limit the ability to comparison shop and budget.
She said companies may use data such as a customer’s IP address, device type, postal code, or information provided during shopping or transactions, and may also use data about behaviour, including how a mouse moves on a web page.
Osborne added that companies may be able to purchase data from data brokers, and Bester said Canadians have over decades created detailed profiles that companies can access, which he said raises concerns when used as the foundation for pricing decisions affecting economic well-being.
The Liberal government told the committee that proposed privacy legislation could be used to tackle surveillance pricing, but that bill does not mention the term.
Ruder told the committee that Canadians may be more familiar with algorithmic pricing in contexts such as travel or ride-sharing, but that groceries are becoming increasingly important.
← More stories