A Wisconsin prosecutor said a Madison police officer acted reasonably when he shot and killed Corey Ruiz and will not face criminal charges.
The Story
A Wisconsin prosecutor announced Thursday that a police officer who shot and killed a 38-year-old Black man in Madison will not face criminal charges, a decision that drew condemnation from the victim’s family and community advocates.
Madison police officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson shot and killed Corey Ruiz on July 22, and the incident was captured on video. The shooting sparked racial justice protests and calls for police reform.
Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne said Ruiz resisted officers, produced a knife and was unaffected by multiple Taser rounds immediately before Baitinger-Peterson fired. Under those circumstances, Ozanne concluded it was “reasonable for the officer to use deadly force,” and there was no “potential criminal court liability.”
Ozanne said he reached his decision after reviewing police reports, diagrams, surveillance videos, police squad car videos and citizen videos. He said Madison police officers do not wear body cameras.
Ozanne’s decision was met with anger outside the shooting site, where bouquets were left and a candlelight vigil was held after dark. The victim’s brother, Adam Ruiz, told reporters the prosecutor had “mistreated” his family, saying, “We’re destroyed,” and adding, “We won’t accept this.”
Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents the Ruiz family, said he believed videos did not justify the shooting, describing what he said showed officers tackling and tasing Ruiz before the officer “executes him.” Crump said he viewed the case as one of the worst excessive force matters he has worked on.
Ozanne said his interpretation of the law was correct, adding that “The law applies equally to members of law enforcement and to those who are not.”
Baitinger-Peterson did not immediately reply to an email seeking comment, and he was described as having more than a decade of experience in law enforcement. Police said he was one of four officers who responded to calls about someone checking out parked cars and an alleged burglary attempt on the day of the shooting.
The video described in the announcement shows officers tussling with Ruiz, who was on a bicycle, in the middle of an intersection. Officers repeatedly yelled, “He’s got a knife! He’s got a knife!” as the weapon was described as visible in Ruiz’s right hand. A fourth officer then deployed a Taser, and Ruiz stumbled and fell to his right side before Baitinger-Peterson fired three shots at close range.
Records released Thursday said Baitinger-Peterson told investigators in an interview days after the shooting that he grabbed Ruiz’s right arm after getting on his knees, realized Ruiz was holding a knife, and feared Ruiz would stab the officers. The records also said Baitinger-Peterson had minor injuries to both hands.
Madison police said Baitinger-Peterson and the other three officers who interacted with Ruiz that day have been on paid administrative leave since the shooting. Chief John Patterson said police will now conduct an internal review and that all officers involved will remain on administrative leave.
Wisconsin Gov.-elect David Crowley urged protesters to stay peaceful and said Ruiz’s killing was “deeply troubling,” adding in a video statement that the decision not to file charges does not end the conversation about the questions the tragedy raised.
The prosecutor’s decision followed the fact that it was the third time since 2012 that Madison police had shot and killed someone in the same neighborhood, according to the announcement.
← More stories