Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan says the federal government’s borrowing and borrowing costs will rise under the spending plans tabled since Budget 2026.
The Story
Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan says parliamentarians should examine more than the size of the deficit when reviewing the Liberal government’s spending plans.
Ryan released a series of reports on Tuesday that analyzed the federal budget tabled Nov. 5 and the broader shift in public finances under Prime Minister Mark Carney.
In a media statement, Ryan said, "The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more," describing the cost of federal measures as $331.6 billion higher in the three spending plans tabled so far under Carney.
Ryan said the government’s overall fiscal situation appears "a bit rosier" than the forecast in Ottawa’s last spending update in April, citing improved revenues tied to better-than-expected economic results and higher global oil prices.
However, Ryan said Ottawa has used up 96 per cent of that new fiscal room through fresh spending commitments rather than meaningfully reducing the deficit.
The Parliamentary Budget Officer projected total borrowing outlined in Budget 2026 will reach $765 billion over five years, which she said is $476 billion more than the cumulative deficit of $289 billion.
Ryan said total borrowing includes loans to Crown corporations and the purchase of assets, noting that much of that debt does not appear directly on Ottawa’s balance sheets.
She also pointed to the Bank of Canada interest rate hike as a factor that will increase borrowing costs for Canadians and governments alike.
Ryan said public debt costs are the fastest-growing line item in the federal budget on a year-over-year basis and are expected to grow larger than the cost of federal health transfers to provinces in the years to come.
During her appearance at the House of Commons’ finance committee on Tuesday, Ryan said taking on debt to pay for spending today means paying the bill in the future.
She said some borrowing costs are paid back through interest on loaned money or returns on investments, but those returns are not guaranteed and loans can go bad.
Ryan also told MPs that investments in items such as military equipment, infrastructure and pipelines come with real costs that must be repaid, "hopefully from successful projects and greater prosperity," but still require repayment if projects do not succeed.
When questioned about Canada’s fiscal position compared with other G7 countries, Ryan said it is "quite favourable," noting that the other six G7 countries are in increasingly difficult fiscal situations.
Ryan said whether Ottawa meets its operating budget anchor depends on how capital is defined, and her report warned that using more internationally accepted definitions could result in Ottawa failing to balance the operating budget over the forecast horizon.
She also said Ottawa’s efforts to restrain program spending are limited to less than half of its expenses because major transfers to persons and provinces are excluded from cost-cutting exercises.
Ryan noted that the government’s effort to reduce public service headcount was close to its target of 332,000 employees as of August 2026, and said staff at Crown corporations are not reflected in the budget, which could change the broader picture.
← More stories