Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand said Global Affairs Canada’s travel advisories are meant to help Canadians assess risks of arbitrary detention in China.
The Story
Foreign Affairs Minister Anita Anand said Global Affairs Canada’s travel advisories can help Canadians judge the risk of arbitrary detention when visiting China, but she did not confirm whether Canadians are safe in the country.
Speaking on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit in Shenzhen, Anand said her department has travel advisories and is ensuring they are “always accurate.”
She said Canada and China are working to strengthen people-to-people ties, including through more flights, more exchanges, and China dropping a visa requirement for Canadian tourists.
Anand also raised concerns about the treatment of Canadians in China, human rights and democratic principles, including freedom of the press, during a Tuesday meeting with her Chinese counterpart, Wang Yi.
The comments came after Prime Minister Mark Carney met with Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen this week and announced renewed funding for university exchanges, along with promises for additional people-to-people partnerships, including in cultural fields.
Anand’s remarks were echoed by Jeff Nankivell, head of the Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada, who said it is important to pursue deeper exchanges while taking China-related risks seriously.
Nankivell said detainment is a concern in China in particular, adding that Canada’s travel advisory indicates “unusual risks” tied to a justice system he said does not meet international standards for issues such as corruption and transparency.
Global Affairs Canada’s China travel advisory, described as the second-lowest risk level of four, advises Canadians to “exercise a high degree of caution” and notes risks of arbitrary detention or being unable to leave the country.
The advisory says Canadian business travellers have been detained and had passports confiscated due to business disputes, and that disputes can be costly and prolonged, potentially leading to a travel ban restricting departures until a matter is resolved.
It also warns that foreign drivers in China can face harsh penalties, including detention if police suspect them of responsibility for road accidents, with cases that can take years to close.
The advisory further states that China can withhold passports for foreigners suspected of a crime, and that it may detain people for up to 37 days without charges.
It warns that Canadians detained on national security charges—such as “upsetting social order”—could face six months of detention before formal arrest, and a trial in a closed court.
For China’s Xinjiang region, the advisory says the United Nations reported in 2022 that serious human rights violations against Uyghurs could constitute crimes against humanity, and that China strongly disputes those findings.
It warns that Chinese authorities are increasingly detaining ethnic and Muslim minorities in the region without due process, including reports of extrajudicial internment and forced labour camps, and says family members of Canadian citizens with Chinese citizenship have been detained.
Nankivell said people in China on student or faculty exchanges, or on their first business trip, can face an ongoing risk of “serious consequences imposed in an arbitrary way,” including scenarios where a person may be caught in the wrong place at the wrong time during a dispute.
He also suggested the highest risk could be connected to business, such as having a falling out with a local partner or knowing a local partner described as a “bad actor” with access to individuals in the local justice system.
Nankivell said it is unlikely Canada would face a full-blown diplomatic crisis in which a senior executive is arrested, and contrasted that with the earlier Two Michaels case in 2018, when China detained two Canadians for more than 1,000 days.
He said Anand raised safety concerns with Wang Yi at the start of their Tuesday meeting, including issues around treatment of Canadians in China and transnational repression, and that regularized communication channels are part of the approach Anand described.
Anand said dialogue with China helps address issues as they emerge, but she would not say whether it lowers the risk of detainment from happening in the first place. “You need to have the fortitude to sit at the table and to raise topics,” she said, adding that she believes they are topics that have “not historically (been) met with a welcome doormat.”
← More stories