The Trump administration urged a federal judge to dissolve a preliminary injunction blocking a two-year closure of Washington’s Kennedy Center for renovations.
The Story
The Trump administration on Nov. 19 urged U.S. District Judge Christopher Cooper to lift a court order that has blocked its plan to close the Kennedy Center’s main building for two years while renovation work is carried out.
Cooper did not rule immediately after hearing arguments on the government’s request to dissolve the preliminary injunction that he issued in May.
In May, Cooper ruled the Kennedy Center board’s vote to close the facility was “ill-informed and seemingly preordained” and did not account for the board’s legal obligations.
The government said in court filings that the Kennedy Center has become “dangerously dilapidated and decrepit,” including a ceiling partially collapsing in early September.
At Thursday’s hearing, Justice Department attorney William Jankowski argued that the court’s review of the board’s decision must be “very, very deferential,” adding, “Plaintiff does not dispute the need for construction at the Kennedy Center.” He told the judge that the board’s decisions were reasonable and “they must stand.”
On the other side, Rep. Joyce Beatty of Ohio, a Democratic member of Congress, sued last December to block Trump’s name from being added to the Kennedy Center, and her legal challenge later extended to the closing plan. Beatty is an ex officio member of the Kennedy Center board.
Beatty’s attorney Nathaniel Zelinsky warned that lifting the order now would “embolden future breaches and misbehavior” by the administration. He urged Cooper to appoint an independent monitor if the injunction is dissolved.
Cooper asked Beatty’s attorney what authority the court has to appoint a monitor. Zelinsky replied that it is “pretty standard trust law.”
The Kennedy Center board voted twice in August and September to close its main building for two years to complete planned repairs. Zelinsky argued in filings that the two-year closure plan was a “Band-Aid” meant to cover up mismanagement and to align with the administration’s aims. The judge also asked what benefit keeping the injunction in place would bring to the center and the public.
Last year, Congress appropriated roughly $257 million for maintenance on the main building at the center’s request. Beatty’s lawyers argued that performing the work in phases, with partial closures spaced out over four years, would let the Kennedy Center remain open to patrons, while government lawyers argued a total closure over two years is the “most cost-effective and efficient path” to address the venue’s infrastructure needs.
← More stories