David Cohen told a foreign affairs committee that a Canada-U.S. trade arrangement may still be reached, while cautioning that U.S. tariffs could continue regardless of U.S. politics.
The Story
David Cohen, a former United States ambassador to Canada, said he remains optimistic that Canada and the United States could reach a bilateral trade deal, but cautioned Canadians not to assume Democrats will be able to rein in President Donald Trump’s tariff policy.
Cohen made the comments by video Monday during testimony to the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development in Ottawa, where he also said the U.S. midterm elections were a historic rebuke of Trump’s policies.
He said it will be difficult for Democrats to persuade enough Republicans to oppose Trump to achieve the supermajority required to bypass a presidential veto, adding that he worries about “unrealistic optimism” that Democrats will quickly end the trade conflict with Canada.
Cohen warned that Democrats may only pursue one tariff tool, while leaving other duties in place that continue to affect parts of the Canadian economy.
In explaining the recent downturn in the relationship, Cohen pointed to the rapid escalation after Ottawa and Washington negotiations broke down in August, when Trump used Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930 to apply 50 per cent levies to a range of Canadian goods and later banned imports of other Canadian products, including motorcycles and some alcohol and dairy products.
Cohen also referenced Trump’s decision to sign an executive order to rename Lake Ontario to Lake America.
He said Prime Minister Carney was right to walk away from trade talks, arguing that Canada had “conducted itself extraordinarily well” under “unfair set of pressures” created by U.S. trade policy.
Cohen told the committee he is hopeful an agreement can be reached by the end of the year or in January, and said even if a temporary arrangement emerges, discussions on the future of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement will continue into next year.
Cohen added that the Trump administration chose not to renew the trilateral pact, CUSMA, in July, which started a rolling annual review and could lead to the agreement expiring if the three countries cannot agree on an extension.
He also said the Canada-U.S. relationship remains durable, but may require a future U.S. administration to apologize for Trump’s rhetoric.
During the same testimony, David MacNaughton, the former Canadian ambassador to Washington during the first Trump presidency, said the current negotiations are different because Trump had advisers “who were sane” during the earlier CUSMA negotiations, and he contrasted that with what he said is an environment where decisions align with the president’s preferences.
MacNaughton told the committee that United States Trade Representative Jamieson Greer is professional, but that final decisions come from the White House.
He said Canada should aim to find a tariff “off-ramp” while also diversifying trade and improving domestic productivity, and he urged Canada to work toward a long-term agreement with the United States.
← More stories