A B.C. Supreme Court judge has quashed a provincial “substantially started” determination for Seabridge Gold’s KSM Project and ordered further consultation with the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation.
The Story
A B.C. Supreme Court judge has ordered that a decision to label a mine in northwestern B.C. as “substantially started” be sent back to the provincial government and that the province provide “deep consultation” with the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation.
The ruling concerns Seabridge Gold’s KSM Project, a proposed copper, gold and silver mine located 65 kilometres northwest of Stewart, B.C., which the province’s assessment officer found in 2024 had substantially started—meaning it had made enough progress to retain its environmental approval.
Justice Emily Burke previously ruled in June that the province had not satisfied its duty to consult the nation about the substantial start decision, and both sides returned to her courtroom seeking clarity on how to interpret that ruling.
In the latest decision, Burke quashed the substantial start determination and directed the province to give the nation 90 days’ notice to submit written arguments addressing whether the project was substantially started.
The Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation said in a statement that after the June ruling, Seabridge issued a news release incorrectly announcing that the court found the substantial start determination reasonable.
Chief Darlene Simpson said her nation is not opposed to responsible resource development, but is concerned about what she described as a “toxic waste dump” that is “52-storey-deep” and “nine-kilometre-long,” using a wet tailings approach that she said has been found unsafe elsewhere.
Simpson said the nation is worried that if the province grants the substantial start determination, it would have to live with the project’s effects on its territory for hundreds of years, because she said the poison “can’t be moved” and poses a risk of breaching containment over time.
With Thursday’s court decision, Simpson said her nation hopes the province will engage seriously with those concerns about “momentous effects” on its territory.
← More stories