Vancouver Television · National

Blue Jays, Rogers silent on potential discipline after Anthony Santander’s anti-Muslim Instagram posts

Blue Jays, Rogers silent on potential discipline after Anthony Santander’s anti-Muslim Instagram posts

Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander apologized last Friday after posting anti-Muslim content on Instagram, and it remains unclear whether the club or Rogers Communications will impose any consequences.

The Story

Toronto Blue Jays outfielder Anthony Santander apologized last Friday for sharing anti-Muslim posts on Instagram, but there has been no public word from the Blue Jays or from the team’s owner, Rogers Communications Inc., about any potential consequences.

The club issued a statement the day before Santander’s apology saying it was “deeply sorry” to its fans and the Muslim community for the pain and harm the posts caused.

Santander, 32, shared the posts on Nov. 4 following the U.S. midterm elections and deleted them the next morning. The posts included videos depicting a Christian preacher saying, “There is no such thing as kind Muslims,” and another suggestion that Sharia law would be imposed on the United States after Abdul El-Sayed was elected to the Senate in Michigan.

Lawyer Brian R. Socolow of Loeb & Loeb LLC said teams and owners are often sensitive to how incidents like the one involving Santander can affect public sentiment.

“I think there's a risk for both the team and the owner, (who) are very much in the public eye and they care about public sentiment for good reason — financial and moral and otherwise,” Socolow said. “So they're very sensitive to how an incident like this can affect them.”

Socolow said organizations may try to manage incidents carefully after an apology, adding that an athlete apologizing can sometimes lead to a “second chance.” He also said professional athletes can be treated differently than other employees, noting that their contracts and leverage can affect outcomes.

It also remains unclear whether Santander violated any social media policy or any “morals” clause in his contract. Socolow said potential termination or discipline would depend on “very specific language” in the relevant clause, and that for anti-Muslim posts to lead to contract termination, the clause would need broad language allowing termination or other discipline based on conduct the team determines is morally offensive.

When asked whether Santander may be disciplined or whether there was a clause violation, a Blue Jays spokesperson said player contracts were “not something we share.” A spokesperson for Rogers suggested connecting with the team on the subject.

Socolow said an approach of letting matters “lie” can sometimes be a temporary strategy for organizations, but he said teams cannot assume issues will disappear when baseball resumes. He noted that Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement with the players’ association is set to expire Dec. 1, with a lockout expected to begin the next day, which could affect a scheduled March 24 season start.

Santander signed a five-year, US$92.5-million deal with the Blue Jays in January 2025. He missed the most recent season due to injuries, and in 2025 he hit .175 with six home runs over 54 games.

The Blue Jays met with leaders from Toronto’s Muslim communities last week. The report cited Statistics Canada data showing Canada’s population includes more than 1.78 million Muslims, and that about 10 per cent of Toronto’s 2.8 million residents identify as Muslim.

← More stories