Vancouver Television · National

What to know about Quebecor’s proposed $31-billion, cash-and-stock merger with Telus

What to know about Quebecor’s proposed $31-billion, cash-and-stock merger with Telus

Quebecor has proposed a merger with Telus in a $31-billion cash-and-stock deal, raising questions about competition, pricing and regulatory approval.

The Story

Quebecor Inc. revealed Monday that it is proposing a merger with Telus in what would be a $31-billion cash-and-stock deal.

The Montreal company’s bid to buy Vancouver-based Telus has prompted questions about whether the combined company would affect wireless prices and competition in Canada’s telecom market.

In the wireless sector, Erik Bohlin, a telecommunications chair at Western University’s Ivey Business School, said moving from four competitors to three would mean “simply less competition,” which could lead to upward price pressure over time.

David McFadgen, managing director of institutional equity research at ATB Cormark Capital Markets, said regulators could be concerned about reducing wireless competitors from four to three, potentially creating a situation in which major players move together on price.

The Competition Bureau has said it found clear evidence that wireless prices are higher in areas without strong regional competition.

The proposed deal could also affect how services are delivered on the ground, as Quebecor has a minimal wireline network outside Quebec and would rely on wholesale access, while Telus buys access wholesale in parts of Quebec.

McFadgen said those wholesale arrangements can limit competitiveness, and that if Quebecor had its own system, it could potentially save money on tapping networks, which it could argue to regulators would result in lower prices.

Carol Liao, a law professor at the University of British Columbia, said Quebecor’s strongest competition argument is that the combined company would have the scale to challenge Rogers and Bell more effectively and invest in networks, but regulators would still need to assess whether customers would have comparable alternatives, including Freedom Mobile.

Liao said regulators would want to understand “where Freedom directly constrains Telus” and how Freedom would develop independently.

She pointed to the 2023 divestment of Freedom by Shaw and Rogers as they completed a merger that produced a $26-billion deal, describing the possibility of a similar conditional outcome.

McFadgen said such a forced approach could involve a spin-off of some wireless assets and noted that many Freedom customers saw lower rates after the sale.

Quebecor CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau is also viewing Telus as a strategic fit due to Telus’s large footprint in Western Canada and, in Quebecor’s perspective, Telus’s troubled growth strategy and weakened stock performance.

Bohlin said a Telus deal would be “a huge complement” because it would provide direct countrywide reach.

Bohlin also said Telus’s growth strategies have run into problems in divisions including Telus International, Telus Health and Telus Agriculture, which he said are on the sell list.

The supplied information says Telus shares were down 32 per cent year-to-date on Friday, and then gained 12.8 per cent on Monday after the potential deal was made public, while the offer would carry a 60 per cent premium.

Bohlin and McFadgen also pointed to differences in control among major telecom companies, with McFadgen saying “Nobody controls Telus,” and adding that Rogers is controlled by the Rogers family.

The supplier included additional competition-related concerns beyond Canada, noting that satellite-based alternatives such as Starlink could affect internet service competition, and mentioning Ottawa-based Telesat as another potential alternative.

← More stories