Vancouver Television · National

Experts warn surveillance pricing could raise grocery costs for people with health or religious restrictions

Experts warn surveillance pricing could raise grocery costs for people with health or religious restrictions

An expert told MPs Monday that algorithmic “surveillance pricing” could lead some grocery shoppers with limited alternatives to pay more.

The Story

People with religious or health-based food restrictions could end up paying more for groceries if businesses use algorithmic pricing that draws on personal information, an expert told MPs on a parliamentary committee Monday in Ottawa.

Sarah-Louise Ruder, an adjunct professor at the University of the Fraser Valley’s food and agriculture institute, made the remarks while responding to Liberal MP Fares Al Soud.

Al Soud said that, as someone who is “Muslim” and “Arab,” he avoids pork and is not a “very effective person” to be advertised alcohol to, and he said similar realities apply to other groups including Hindu Canadians, Jewish Canadians and people with celiac.

He asked whether AI-driven pricing systems create a risk that these consumers “end up paying more, precisely because their purchasing patterns reveal they have fewer alternatives.”

Ruder responded that it is “absolutely” the case, adding that inferences tied to what someone buys regularly can affect their inferred willingness to pay in ways that could have negative impacts for different cultural practices and households.

Renjie Butalid, co-founder of the Montreal AI Ethics Institute, told the House of Commons ethics committee that there should be a clear line between pricing based on market conditions and surveillance pricing that uses personal information to set individualized prices.

He gave the example of a parent urgently buying baby formula who may have few alternatives, describing how a surveillance pricing system could use that to charge the parent more.

Butalid recommended “a general prohibition on surveillance pricing where businesses use personal information, behavioral data, or inferences about individual consumers to determine individualized prices.”

The Liberal government says its proposed privacy legislation could be used to address the issue, although the bill does not mention the term “surveillance pricing.”

← More stories