Vancouver Television · Local

Poilievre slams Carney’s oligopoly comments as Quebecor eyes $31B cash-and-stock bid for Telus

Poilievre slams Carney’s oligopoly comments as Quebecor eyes $31B cash-and-stock bid for Telus

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre said Prime Minister Mark Carney’s remarks on oligopolies show he favours corporate interests as Quebecor considers a takeover bid for Telus.

The Story

Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre criticized Prime Minister Mark Carney’s comments about the potential effects of oligopolies in the context of ongoing talks between Quebecor and Telus.

Carney told reporters Wednesday that competition, lower prices and better service would be key to any federal decision if the companies’ discussions lead to an agreement for Ottawa to review. He also said that under certain circumstances, and depending on market structure, an oligopoly situation can lead to more competition with fewer players, while providing no further detail.

Poilievre said he disagreed, telling reporters Friday he has “never seen any economist anywhere in the world” make that argument. “Mr. Carney has been wrong about a lot of things, but I have never seen a more ridiculous economic analysis from anyone than what he said the other day, that less competition actually brings prices down,” Poilievre said.

Poilievre said the Conservatives have “not seen the proposal yet,” adding that shareholders have not approved it and that the Competition Bureau has not yet had a chance to investigate. He said the decision would be judged by one principle: whether it will “lower costs for consumers.”

Quebecor revealed Monday it is eyeing a $31-billion takeover of Telus in a cash-and-stock deal. Telus has cited “serious concerns” about the offer, including how the company could survive regulatory scrutiny, and Telus says it is continuing to review the bid rather than accept it.

Quebecor’s offer is also disputed by Telus leadership: Telus president and CEO Victor Dodig said the bid undervalues Telus.

Quebecor president and CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau has pitched the merger as a way to save cash by combining networks, spectrum and operations to boost investment capacity, and he argued a stronger company would better protect “sovereignty” in the Canadian telecommunications sector as foreign competitors such as Elon Musk’s Starlink gain market share.

The companies’ next steps were set for Monday, when Dodig and Péladeau are slated to meet to discuss next steps.

Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said on Friday that the Quebecor proposal is still an intent at this point, and that federal review processes would apply. “The Competition Bureau, the CRTC and the powers we have under the Telecommunications (Act) and the Radiocommunication Act will be enforced,” Joly said.

Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi said potential reviews would occur in parallel and are not dependent on one another, noting that the Competition Bureau, the spectrum role under ISED and the CRTC’s broadcasting-licence review each apply different tests.

Yaghi also pointed to the framework created by Ottawa’s approval of the 2023 Rogers-Shaw combination, including a spectrum transfer moratorium that remains in place. He said that would stand as an early regulatory hurdle for Quebecor to clear.

As for the economics of the proposed consolidation, University of Calgary economics professor Aidan Hollis said in an earlier interview that having more industry players generally leads to greater competition, while adding that an exception can occur if an “inefficient” competitor with a small market share is absorbed, potentially producing a “more effective competitor.”

Yaghi cautioned against assigning deal probabilities at this stage, saying too many variables remain unknown. He also said, without a revised spectrum framework and a defined remedy package, the Competition Bureau’s review would likely be difficult for Quebecor to pass, estimating low completion odds without a material change in Quebecor’s position.

← More stories