Quebecor says a potential merger between BCE and Telus “would not represent a positive outcome for consumers” and warned it would worsen practices it disputes at Bell.
The Story
Quebecor is criticizing the prospect of BCE and Telus joining forces after Telus revealed earlier this week that it is being pursued, with industry observers also suggesting Bell could become involved.
In a statement issued Thursday, Quebecor said that while interest by Bell’s parent company in acquiring Telus “bolsters its argument for a strengthened three-player telecom market,” a Bell–Telus merger “would not represent a positive outcome for consumers.”
“Bell’s track record with its customers speaks for itself,” Quebecor said, pointing to the volume of consumer complaints about Bell in annual watchdog reports and citing price increases and a recently introduced fee being reviewed by the national telecom regulator as potential violations of a ban on activation and cancellation charges.
Quebecor also said that Telus “has also engaged in such practices with its customers” and that it was “called to order by the CRTC for doing so,” adding, “A merger of the two companies would only exacerbate these practices.”
Quebecor’s statement argued that its own proposal would benefit consumers and said that since acquiring Freedom Mobile, it has “embodied that vision.” It also said the “arrival of Quebecor would bring a breath of fresh air that would benefit Canadians.”
Quebecor announced on Monday that it is eyeing a $31-billion takeover of Telus, while Telus said it has “serious concerns” about the offer. Telus said it has not accepted the proposal and is continuing to review it.
Telus president and CEO Victor Dodig said the proposal undervalues his company and that he has concerns about how an offer, if accepted, would satisfy regulators.
The possible Bell–Telus move is being assessed by telecom analysts, including Desjardins’ Jerome Dubreuil, who said it is “natural for BCE to kick the tires,” citing a longstanding wireless network sharing agreement. Dubreuil also warned that regulatory hurdles could be significant, noting that obtaining Competition Bureau approval for a combination of two Big Three members “would likely be a long shot.”
Dubreuil said that without further moves to resolve regulatory concerns, a combined Bell–Telus company would control 55 per cent of Canada’s wireless market, compared with a Quebecor–Telus merger at 40 per cent. He also said a Bell–Telus merger could create “significant synergies,” but starting after Quebecor could require BCE to put forward a more compelling offer.
In the government’s review process, Industry Minister Mélanie Joly said the government “will not predetermine the outcomes.” On Wednesday, Prime Minister Mark Carney said more competition, lower prices and better service would be key to any decision, while saying he would not comment directly on Quebecor’s proposal.
Quebecor said it made a non-binding proposal to Telus on June 26, and then submitted an “enhanced proposal” on Nov. 9. A potential transaction would likely trigger reviews by the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada.
Quebecor president and CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau said in an interview on Monday that he is pitching the merger as a way to save cash by combining networks, spectrum and operations to boost investment capacity, and he has also described Quebecor as a fourth national carrier since acquiring Freedom Mobile in 2023. Péladeau and Dodig are scheduled to meet Monday to discuss next steps.
← More stories