Food-safety researchers say everyday washing with warm, soapy water may be enough, but boards should be sanitized after raw meat or poultry using methods such as boiling water, a dishwasher sanitize cycle, or diluted bleach.
The Story
Cutting boards are routinely used for everything from raw chicken to onions, and the key food-safety question is not only whether wood or plastic is safer, but how to clean and care for the board you already have, according to food-science researcher Donald Schaffner.
Schaffner, a professor of food science at Rutgers University, said, “I think the real question is not which is safer, but are they both safe to use?” He studies how bacteria move between surfaces. He noted that for years plastic boards were viewed as safer mainly because they appeared easier to clean, but earlier research has complicated that view.
In the 1990s, Dean Cliver, a food safety researcher at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, placed salmonella and E. coli on wood boards and found bacteria were pulled down into the wood, where they did not multiply and eventually died off. Schaffner said the research is “a bit muddied,” but Cliver’s work showed “wood was not as risky as we thought.”
Beyond the wood–plastic comparison, Schaffner pointed to the practical reality that plastic boards can be harder to fully clean once they become scratched. He said bacteria-harboring residue like chicken fat can settle into knife grooves and be difficult to scrub out by hand.
Wood can also offer some built-in advantages, with natural antimicrobial compounds that appear to help “at least somewhat,” according to Schaffner. Nicole Papantoniou, senior director of the Kitchen & Cooking Lab at the Good Housekeeping Institute, said she doesn’t pick a side and uses both wood and plastic boards.
Papantoniou also said she likes composite cutting boards made from wood or paper fibers bonded with resin because they are light and hold up well, and she cited a paper composite board made by Epicurean as a winner of Good Housekeeping’s 2027 Kitchen Awards.
Epicurean CEO Dave Benson said knife cuts in composite stay open instead of closing back over bits of food the way they can on plastic, which he said makes the boards easier to clean. Schaffner added there is not much independent research yet comparing how composite or bamboo boards stack up against wood and plastic.
For everyday use, Papantoniou said washing with warm, soapy water and letting the board air dry is enough. She said sanitation is an extra step that should happen after a board has already been cleaned, to kill bacteria that washing can leave behind.
Schaffner said hot tap water isn’t a reliable substitute for sanitizing. He said, “If the water were hot enough to actually kill bacteria, it would also burn our hands.” He described three sanitation options after raw meat or poultry: carefully pouring boiling water over a clean board, running the board through the dishwasher on the sanitize cycle, or using diluted bleach according to the bottle directions.
Schaffner said vinegar and hydrogen peroxide “are not very effective, at least not nearly as effective as bleach.” He also said wood boards should be washed by hand, since the dishwasher or a long sink soak can warp or crack the wood.
Plastic and composite boards, by contrast, can go in the dishwasher. Schaffner said he saves plastic boards for raw meat and poultry, and called keeping separate boards for raw meat and produce “a perfectly reasonable food safety precaution,” though he said it is not a must.
To reduce spread of bacteria, Schaffner emphasized that bacteria travel with water. He warned that a wet chicken breast can spread germs to the board, to hands, and to whatever is grabbed next.
Wood boards require additional care beyond cleaning. Papantoniou said wood boards should be oiled and kept conditioned to keep them in good shape over time, and she advised starting when the board is new. She also said wood boards should dry standing on their edges so air can get to both sides.
John Boos & Co., which has made butcher block cutting boards in Effingham, Illinois, since 1887, recommends oiling once a month, and more often if the board is used daily. Lisa Bosio, vice president of group marketing at the company, said the wood looks lighter and a little dry when it’s time to oil, and she advised using a food-safe mineral oil applied in a light layer, left to soak in overnight and wiped off in the morning.
For stubborn stains, Noah Pinsonnault of the Good Housekeeping Institute suggested using 3% hydrogen peroxide left on for about five minutes, then rinsing it off. Pinsonnault said peroxide is a mild bleach and can lighten wood—especially darker varieties like walnut—so it should be tried on a small spot first.
If a board smells like last night’s garlic, Pinsonnault said to scrub it with a paste of baking soda and water, rinse and then let it dry completely. Finally, when deciding whether to replace a board, Schaffner said he gets rid of one when it becomes increasingly hard to get it visibly clean.
Papantoniou said she throws out boards that warp, plastic boards with deep grooves or little curls that could end up in food, and wood boards that crack or develop dark spots that could be moldy.
← More stories