Vancouver Television · International

Erin Moriarity says fear-driven Social Security timing can lead to “worse decisions”

Erin Moriarity says fear-driven Social Security timing can lead to “worse decisions”

YouTube creator Erin Moriarity, speaking on Morningstar’s podcast, argued that people should avoid claiming Social Security early based on fear and instead plan using budgeting and income needs.

The Story

YouTube creator Erin Moriarity appeared on Morningstar’s The Long View and discussed Social Security benefits, including why she feels positive about the future of Social Security benefits.

When asked about why people over 50 should feel comfort about promised benefits, Moriarity said, “People over 50 vote, and those in Congress know it,” adding that she believes Congress has “huge motivation to act.”

Moriarity said she expects “Social Security will experience reform and will see changes,” but she said she does not necessarily know what the changes would be. She also said the common narrative that Social Security is going bankrupt is “not true,” saying current workers pay into the system that pays current retirees.

In response to how younger people should handle potential future benefit changes, Moriarity said that for people in their 20s, 30s and early 40s, she does not want them “considering Social Security at that point,” and instead urged them to save and invest so they are not relying on those benefits.

For people in their late 40s, 50s and especially in their 60s, Moriarity said they should examine what benefits are expected, then “build my budget” to identify the gap between Social Security and how much they want to spend.

Asked about big Social Security pitfalls, Moriarity said one major mistake is thinking the trust fund will be totally depleted, leaving no benefits or leading to cuts, and she criticized a fear-based approach to early claiming. She said she hears people saying, “Claim as early as you can so you can get something while it’s there,” and added, “I just think that that’s a fearful mentality,” saying “The more we operate out of fear, the worse decisions we tend to make.”

Moriarity said decisions should be based on planning needs, describing the value of “a reliable income stream that is inflation-adjusted for the remainder of your life.” She said people should look at their portfolio and the gap they can fill and make a decision based on their budget for the next couple of decades.

For married people, Moriarity said to factor in that “one of you is going to pass away first” and that in many cases it can make sense for the higher-earning spouse to delay, because the surviving spouse can keep the higher earner’s benefit.

← More stories