Vancouver Television · National

Bank of Canada deputy governor Toni Gravelle cautions against heavy forward guidance in uncertain times

Bank of Canada deputy governor Toni Gravelle cautions against heavy forward guidance in uncertain times

Deputy governor Toni Gravelle said in Edmonton that too much forward guidance can leave markets reacting to the Bank of Canada rather than incoming data.

The Story

Deputy governor Toni Gravelle told the Edmonton Chamber of Commerce on Wednesday that central banks face good reasons to keep interest-rate thinking less explicit when uncertainty is high, while also trying to be more upfront about their thinking.

Gravelle raised concerns that extensive forward guidance—where interest rates could go next—can leave markets “parroting the Bank of Canada” instead of responding to new information that could change the rate path.

He said the issue is especially pronounced when the future is heavily uncertain, noting that expectations about future interest rate moves are almost as important as current decisions and are reflected in long-term bond yields that influence rates on many Canadian loans and savings instruments.

Gravelle also echoed criticisms attributed to Kevin Warsh, the new chair of the U.S. Federal Reserve, who argued in August that sharing too much of a prospective rate path can lock policymakers into future decisions or mislead markets and households.

To illustrate how the Bank of Canada approaches uncertainty, Gravelle pointed to the use of scenarios, including one from April in which higher-than-forecast global oil prices persisted; he said that scenario closely matched the actual oil-price path through the spring and summer.

Gravelle said the April scenario included an expectation that inflation would stay close to three per cent for more than a year and that consecutive policy rate increases would be needed to return inflation to target, adding that the upside inflation risk identified in April had largely materialized.

He said outlining scenarios and possible Bank of Canada reactions helps Canadians understand shifts in policy stance, and he reiterated that the central bank is committed to improving public understanding of interest-rate decisions.

The Bank of Canada’s policy rate currently stands at 2.5 per cent, with its final decision of the year set for Dec. 9.

← More stories