Vancouver Television · Local

Crown prosecutor reads victim impact statement during sentencing submissions for former Penticton councillor James Miller

Crown prosecutor reads victim impact statement during sentencing submissions for former Penticton councillor James Miller

Sentencing submissions in Ontario Superior Court included a victim impact statement read aloud by Crown prosecutor Suzanne LaSha during the case of former Penticton councillor James Miller.

The Story

Sentencing submissions were heard on Thursday in Ontario Superior Court for James Miller, the former Penticton city councillor convicted of historic sexual offences against youth.

Before the sentencing arguments began, Crown prosecutor Suzanne LaSha read a victim impact statement from a man now in his 40s, describing the impact the offences had from when he was 11 years old.

In the statement, the victim said he was scared and had “no way to say what was really wrong,” and described self-medicating with drugs and alcohol beginning at age 13.

The victim said that by age 17, he was kicked out of his house and became homeless, and he wrote that he continues to struggle with intimacy because it brings him back to memories involving Miller.

LaSha proposed a four- to six-year-long prison sentence, arguing Miller showed a regular pattern of offending and suggesting the long-term effect on the victim should be a factor when determining sentence.

During submissions, the court heard that the charges stem from Miller’s time as a youth basketball coach in the Sarnia, Ont., area more than 30 years ago.

The court also heard that Miller would take the victim on out-of-town sports trips and spend one-on-one time with him before the sexual offences took place, as described in the submissions.

Defence lawyer Donald Elliot argued for a conditional sentence of 18 to 24 months, pointing to Miller’s lack of prior criminal record.

Elliot also said Miller has already experienced consequences following the conviction, including being fired as editor of the Penticton Herald and losing his position on city council.

The judge agreed with the defence’s position on a pre-sentence report concern about unemployment increasing risk of reoffending, and said, “I don’t buy that for a New York minute.”

A sentencing decision in the case has been pushed to Jan. 28.

← More stories