Ernest Hemingway’s centennial novel ‘The Sun Also Rises’ was marked in New York while scholars said women now play leading roles in Hemingway scholarship.
The Story
This year marks the 100th anniversary of Ernest Hemingway’s breakout novel, “The Sun Also Rises,” and scholars and readers say the author’s once-dominant legend has receded enough for the books to be judged on their own terms.
Hilary K. Justice, an Ernest Hemingway scholar at Boston’s John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum, said that as a graduate student she was told studying Hemingway amounted to “committing professional suicide.” She recalled a professor’s comment: “Haven’t we killed him yet?” Justice oversees the Hemingway collection at the JFK library, where the author’s papers are stored.
Justice said she previously heard questions tied to her gender at public talks, including: “How do you, as a woman, justify studying Hemingway?” She and other Hemingway scholars said they generally encounter little resistance now.
A centennial event held last month at the 92nd Street Y Unterberg Poetry Center in Manhattan included readings of “The Sun Also Rises” by actors including Maya Hawke, Will Harrison and Sarah Pidgeon. A panel discussion featured “Bright Lights, Big City” novelist Jay McInerney and a handful of Hemingway descendants, including Justice’s grandson, Brendan Hemingway.
Brendan Hemingway, who said he was a teenager during the rise of second-wave feminism in the 1970s, described classmates approaching him in high school to say they despised Hemingway. “People decided that they'd project on to me whatever they liked or didn't like about Ernest Hemingway and were surprised that wasn't a great experience for me,” he said. “And the big thing for me at 100 (years of ‘The Sun Also Rises’) is for my daughter's generation that's all gone. We've outlasted the baggage. We've outrun the backlash. For my daughter's generation, you read him or you don't.”
Other scholars said they are more likely to encounter the work itself before the surrounding myth. Verna Kale, an associate research professor at Penn State, said she recently asked a group of students if they had ever read Hemingway and was told none had. Ross K. Tangedal, an associate professor at the University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point and a member of the Hemingway Letters Project editorial team, said his students are usually “exposed to his work in small doses in high school,” so in college they encounter “the work before the myth.”
Published in 1926, “The Sun Also Rises” follows British and American expatriates adrift in Europe, living on “sex, alcohol, boxing and bullfights.” The novel helped define the “Lost Generation” that followed the First World War, and McInerney said he first read it in college and remembered it “blew me away.”
McInerney told the audience that when it was published, the book “essentially revolutionized English prose,” calling it “a really radical new voice” that “somehow still spoke directly” to him.
Scholars also discussed how Hemingway’s reputation and the treatment of characters in his work are viewed today. Debra Moddelmog, on the editorial board of The Hemingway Review, said many readers who know Hemingway’s image see women in his books as stereotyped and marginalized, but she described Hemingway as “deceptive” and said close reading reveals complex characters rather than stereotypes.
Justice said women now hold many of the leading roles in Hemingway scholarship, including Moddelmog; Sandra Spanier, general editor of the Hemingway Letters Project; and Suzanne del Gizzo, editor of The Hemingway Review. Kale, who edits a Norton Library edition of “The Sun Also Rises,” said she never had “any misgivings” about studying Hemingway and described her focus shift after reading the novel on a trip to Europe. “I was just the right age to read it, and I became very interested in the expatriate modernists,” she said. “I’ve never had any misgivings about studying Hemingway whatsoever. I find his writing captivating, and documenting his life through his letters has become my life’s work.”
← More stories