Matthew Schaefer completes first NHL hat trick as New York Islanders down Columbus 5-1 at UBS Arena
Image accompanying the official NHL announcement.ELMONT, N.Y. — Matthew Schaefer turned a key moment late in the third period into a milestone, completing his first NHL hat trick in the New York Islanders’ 5-1 win against the Columbus Blue Jackets on Tuesday at UBS Arena. Schaefer scored his third goal at 16:08 of the third, as the Islanders maintained a three-goal lead when Columbus pulled its goaltender.
Schaefer had already scored twice before his hat trick, and the game situation created the sixth opportunity he needed to reach the rare accomplishment in his first 100 NHL games. With Columbus opting to pull goaltender Cam Talbot, Schaefer said he recognized the chance unfolding in real time. “I was out there and I didn’t know if they were (going to pull Cam Talbot) or not, and I see them pull him and I’m like, ‘Oh!’” Schaefer said. “They got to do what they got to do. We were just focused on the game and if it happened, it happened. If it didn’t, it’s not the end of the world. We just want to win in here.”
By reaching the three-goal mark, Schaefer became the first New York Islanders defenseman to record a hat trick since Denis Potvin accomplished the feat on March 4, 1982. After the goal, he skated toward Islanders goaltender Ilya Sorokin, waving his hands at the crowd as he celebrated, an action Schaefer later described with a sense of humour. “It might’ve been a little too hard of a celly,” Schaefer said. “Maybe I should have been a little more respectful with it, but it’s awesome. Anytime something like that happens … it’s pretty cool, but it was just a big win in general overall with a great team effort.”
Schaefer’s night also continued a pattern of record-setting production before the hat trick even landed. In the second period, he made it 2-0 at 1:34 with a wrist shot from the edge of the right face-off circle. The NHL noted that he became only the second defenseman in league history to reach 30 career goals as a teenager, joining Hockey Hall of Famer Phil Housley (46).
His goals weren’t just plentiful; they also moved him across several milestone lists. At 7:01 of the third, Schaefer backhanded a rebound past Talbot to make it 3-1. In doing so, he passed Housley in total multigoal games, with six career multi-goal games, the most by a teenage defenseman in NHL history. The NHL further reported that with his 17th career multipoint game, Schaefer passed Larry Murphy and Rick Hampton and tied Ray Bourque for the second most by a teenage defenseman, behind Housley (34).
Entering the hat trick moment, the NHL reported that Schaefer had 24 points through 20 games in the season, with nine goals and 15 assists, tying Murphy (1980-81) for the second most by a teenage defenseman through that span, behind Housley (25; nine goals, 16 assists in 1983-84). The NHL also noted that Schaefer’s nine goals matched Housley for the most by a teenage defenseman through 20 games.
Schaefer addressed the broader historical context of his production while keeping the focus on team priorities. “All these things, it’s just crazy to hear. It’s an honor,” he said. “You don't think about things like that, but obviously when you hear it, it's pretty cool. But you just want to keep focusing on your season and what we've got going on in here.”
The Islanders’ coaching staff and teammates framed Schaefer’s style of play as part of what makes the accomplishment stand out. Head coach Peter DeBoer, who has been the team’s coach for 24 games dating to last season, commented on Schaefer’s enthusiastic celebrations. Speaking with a laugh, DeBoer said, “I’m not going to throw anyone under the bus, but he had somebody whispering in his ear that (the celebration) was a good idea. I’m not sure that was all him; I think he was following some instructions, a guy he trusted, which was unfortunate.” DeBoer added that the enthusiasm is something he wants the player to keep, describing it as “genuine” and “what the game's about.”
Forward Mathew Barzal, in his 10th full NHL season with the Islanders, also spoke to Schaefer’s impact on the defensive end and the energy he brings. Barzal said, “We’re watching greatness kind of evolve,” and added that he sees growing consistency. He also described Schaefer’s enthusiasm as a key part of the entertainment value for fans and stated that having a player of Schaefer’s level on the roster is meaningful for the organization.
After the game, the NHL reported that Schaefer received the puck used for his third goal of the night. He said he would give it to his father, Todd, who often attends games but was back home in Stoney Creek, Ontario on Tuesday. Islanders forward Anthony Duclair said in the locker room, “That’s just how special he is, and that’s the first of many,” adding that he expects Schaefer’s hat trick achievement to be followed by more milestones.
With the hat trick and the broader record movements, Schaefer’s performance added another chapter to the Islanders franchise history while also reinforcing his fast-rising place among NHL teenage defensemen. The result gave New York a decisive 5-1 win over the Blue Jackets at UBS Arena.
Reporting source: NHL official update
Homepage ↗