MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred says owners are “100% unanimous” on salary cap and floor as CBA clock approaches Dec. 1
Image accompanying the official MLB announcement.Major League Baseball is moving closer to the Dec. 1 expiration of its Collective Bargaining Agreement, and Commissioner Rob Manfred said the league’s negotiating position leaves little room to separate economic terms from a proposed salary cap and floor. Speaking at a press conference after owners meetings at the league office, Manfred said, “The owners want a deal with a salary cap and floor,” adding, “I know there’s a lot of rhetoric out there that characterizes this as not serious or whatever. It’s serious.”
Manfred said the league’s ownership group is fully aligned behind the cap-and-floor framework. He told reporters that the 30 clubs are “100% unanimous in support of the proposals that have been made” and said he “can’t imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor.” He linked that stance to competitive balance, arguing it is a “serious problem” that “needs to be addressed” and that the league is not prepared to tell fans that they are wrong on the economics of the system.
In response, the MLB Players Association issued a statement through interim executive director Bruce Meyer that directly addressed Manfred’s comments. Meyer said the owners’ insistence on negotiating “outside of a radical change” would dramatically reduce overall player compensation across categories and strip fundamental rights, including the ability to have “truly guaranteed contracts.” Meyer also said the union sees the owners’ push as motivated by profit and franchise-value increases through artificially suppressing player salaries.
Manfred’s remarks framed the negotiations as a dispute over what the league believes are practical bargaining proposals versus what he described as rhetoric from the union. He acknowledged that he expects the process will involve “plenty of room for compromise,” but said the one area he “will not compromise” is the core economic structure tied to a cap and floor. He argued that, while MLB has accepted several items put forward by the MLBPA, the union has not engaged in discussions about the central economic system being proposed by MLB.
Manfred said MLB’s approach includes offering changes within the cap-and-floor framework to address concerns raised by the MLBPA. He cited a “big increase in the minimum,” an increase in the pre-arbitration bonus pool, and said MLB has agreed to the union’s proposal on free agency “for the first time since the ’70s.” He characterized those steps as part of a “classic collective bargaining effort to address the other party’s concerns while preserving your own.”
The commissioner also suggested that the union has not made “any meaningful effort to move towards” MLB’s position. In his comments, Manfred said the MLBPA has repeatedly described MLB’s proposals as “not real or not serious,” criticized and mischaracterized elements of the cap-and-floor plan, and has offered limited economic counterproposal progress even on topics that he said do not directly impact the league’s economics.
Beyond day-to-day bargaining, Manfred referenced competitive balance arguments in public remarks. He pointed to the most recent small-market World Series matchup between the Brewers and Rays and said that Milwaukee became the first small-market club to win a championship since the 2015 Royals. Manfred said he does not want baseball to treat that outcome as unusual and described his goal as making it possible for similar results to occur more regularly, like in other sports.
Lockout contingency planning was also part of the commissioner’s message. Manfred said his “overriding objective” is to reach an agreement and play an uninterrupted 162-game schedule. He cited that the last CBA negotiations produced a complete schedule after “March 10” of that bargaining cycle, though he described the previous outcome as involving “minor tweaks.” He also said a decision on whether to lock out “is one that we’re going to make at the last possible moment.”
Manfred addressed why he believes the negotiations may not differ fundamentally from past rounds even if the league’s cap-and-floor plan is central this time. He said the “real culprit” is not the existence of the cap-and-floor proposal, pointing instead to the 2022 negotiations and characterizing Meyer’s public description of that CBA. Manfred said the league in the last round did not propose cap and floor, yet the negotiations got close to an outcome that would have affected games being played. He also said Meyer described a series of sequentially improved proposals from ownership designed to avoid losing games.
The league’s most recent proposal, according to Manfred, includes a salary cap of $258.2 million and a floor of $180.2 million, with a system that would begin in the 2028 season. He also laid out how the cap and floor would affect payrolls based on end-of-season 2026 numbers. Manfred said 12 clubs—Marlins, Guardians, Cardinals, Rays, Nationals, White Sox, Twins, Rockies, Pirates, Athletics, Reds and Brewers—would be required to increase payroll by a combined $636 million to meet the floor, while eight clubs—Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, Blue Jays, Padres, Red Sox and Cubs—would need to reduce payroll by a combined $528 million to meet the cap.
Along with the cap and floor, Manfred said MLB has proposed multiple related changes. He cited earlier access to free agency for players at least 30 years old with five years of service time, the elimination of the qualifying offer system, increases to both minimum salaries and the pre-arbitration bonus pool, rules changes intended to reduce roster churn, and Rule 5 Draft changes to help players reach the Majors sooner. He also argued that his proposal would establish a 50-50 split of revenue and guarantee players 50% of revenue, ending what he described as a “two-decade decline” in player compensation’s share of revenue.
From MLBPA’s side, Manfred said the union made its initial proposal in May, including changes to the reserve system from six years to five for players 30 and older, elimination of the qualifying offer system, increases to the minimum salary, and changes to both the Competitive Balance Tax threshold and a competitive integrity tax. Manfred said MLB accepted some MLBPA proposals but “only in a cap and floor system,” arguing that the union’s proposals would exacerbate competitive problems rather than resolve them.
With the CBA expiration approaching in less than two weeks, Manfred said what comes next is ongoing bargaining focused on the priorities reflected in the MLBPA’s proposals and a willingness by MLB to modify the cap-and-floor system to address criticisms. He told reporters that those steps are the two paths by which negotiations “move to the middle,” and he said MLB will remain committed to reaching an agreement “good for our fans and fair to the players.”
Reporting source: MLB official update
Homepage ↗