An aviation management expert says Canada’s air-traffic control system is more robust than the one operated by the U.S. FAA, and that Canada’s systems were not affected by Friday’s U.S. outage.
The Story
An aviation management expert says Canada is less likely than the United States to ground flights nationwide in the way the FAA did on Friday afternoon, pointing to differences in how the two countries’ air-traffic systems are run.
John Gradek, a faculty lecturer in supply networks and aviation management at McGill University, said Canada’s system is more robust and modernized than the FAA’s. “They should look north — they should look to Canada,” Gradek said. He argued that taking air-traffic control out of politicians’ influence helps keep the system from becoming vulnerable to political funding decisions, adding: “If the system can go down the way it did Friday night… and it brings down the whole of the U.S. aviation system, something is wrong.”
In the United States, the FAA issued a so-called ground stop order on Friday, citing communications issues affecting nearly two dozen air traffic control centres that direct planes en route between airports across the country. Airports across Canada suspended flights to and from the United States, and Air Canada said late Friday it was cancelling the rest of those flights for the rest of the day. The U.S. order was lifted late Friday and flights resumed, but airlines warned it could take days to return to normal operations.
On Sunday, the U.S. FAA described a radar site in Amarillo, Texas, and a radio communications site in El Dorado, Arkansas, as potential sources of the problem. The issue involved excess data flooding the air-traffic control system and causing intermittent disruptions to communications and radar feeds. U.S. Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy said after a contractor replaced old copper wire with new fibre wire at the Arkansas site and the router was turned on, a problem then surfaced in Texas, cascading into the ground stop.
Gradek attributed much of the fragility he described to the U.S. funding model, saying the FAA operates with outdated equipment instead of modern fibre optic cables that can handle higher data surges. In contrast, he said NAV Canada, the air navigation service provider in Canada, operates outside of government and collects its funding from airline ticket sales, which he said helps shield the non-profit organization from political decisions about how much resources to allocate.
NAV Canada said in an emailed statement that its systems were not affected by the Friday outage in the United States and that air-traffic services in Canadian airspace continue to operate normally. The company pointed to $3.5 billion it invested in the air-traffic management system and related infrastructure, adding through spokesperson Maryam Amini that “redundancy is built in at multiple levels,” including backup systems and established contingency procedures that its teams train on regularly so operations can continue safely.
← More stories