Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan says three spending plans tabled under Prime Minister Mark Carney carry federal costs projected to be $331.6 billion higher.
The Story
Parliamentary Budget Officer Annette Ryan urged parliamentarians to scrutinize the federal government’s spending plans beyond the size of the deficit, releasing a set of reports Tuesday that analyze the federal budget tabled Nov. 5 and the broader shift in public finances under Prime Minister Mark Carney.
Ryan said the government promised “to spend less to invest more,” but her office projected that the cost of federal measures is $331.6 billion higher in the three spending plans tabled so far under Carney.
She said the Liberal government’s overall fiscal situation is “a bit rosier” than the forecast in Ottawa’s last spending update in April, citing improved revenues tied to better-than-expected economic results and a boost from higher global oil prices. However, Ryan said Ottawa has used 96 per cent of that new fiscal room through fresh spending commitments rather than meaningfully reducing the deficit.
Ryan also projected that total borrowing outlined in Budget 2026 is expected to reach $765 billion over five years—$476 billion more than the cumulative deficit of $289 billion. She noted that total borrowing includes loans to Crown corporations and the purchase of assets, meaning much of the debt does not appear directly on Ottawa’s balance sheets.
The PBO warned that borrowing costs are set to rise for governments and Canadians after the Bank of Canada interest rate hike, and said public debt costs are the fastest-growing line item on a year-over-year basis in the federal budget.
During appearances before the House of Commons’ finance committee, Ryan told MPs that taking on debt to pay for spending today means paying the bill in the future, and that while some returns come through interest or investment performance, loans can go bad and returns are not guaranteed.
Ryan said investments now in items such as military equipment and infrastructure have “very real costs” that must be paid back, noting that the responsibility remains even if projects do not deliver expected outcomes.
Conservative finance critic Michael Chong argued Tuesday that the Liberals are not on a fiscally sustainable track, adding that interest on the national debt is consuming more than federal spending on public health care.
At the committee, Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne said, when questioned about the decision to spend rather than pay down debt, “Confident countries invest,” while he added that Canada is among the few G7 countries that can afford to do so by investing in growth while supporting Canadians through affordability measures.
Champagne’s spokesperson John Fragos said the government’s borrowing beyond its means is focused on generating future growth and setting the stage for greater investments in Canada, arguing that Canada’s economy is still growing despite a U.S. trade dispute and that foreign direct investment is rising.
The PBO also said Ottawa’s efforts to restrain program spending are limited to less than half of its expenses, since major transfers to persons and provinces are excluded from cost-cutting exercises. It added that staff at Crown corporations are not reflected in the budget and that expanding the measure could change the trend.
Ryan said Budget 2026 moves toward Carney’s capital agenda but raised concerns about how the government defines capital versus operating spending, adding in her report that the anchor’s success depends on how capital is defined and that using internationally accepted definitions would mean Ottawa would fail to balance its operating budget over the forecast horizon.
← More stories