Vancouver Television · National

Nova Scotia auditor finds issues with environmental assessments for onshore wind projects

Nova Scotia auditor finds issues with environmental assessments for onshore wind projects

Nova Scotia Auditor General Kim Adair released an audit calling for changes to the province’s environmental assessment process and post-approval monitoring for onshore wind projects.

The Story

Nova Scotia Auditor General Kim Adair released the findings of an audit Tuesday that urged the province to strengthen how it handles environmental assessments for onshore wind energy development and how it monitors projects after approvals are issued.

The audit included a survey of public servants with scientific expertise who work on environmental assessments. Adair said 38 people who had worked on assessments of onshore wind projects since 2023 responded to the survey, and respondents reported feeling “muzzled,” being “directed” not to suggest terms and conditions, or being pressured to “alter or soften” their comments.

Adair’s report also described cases where risks identified by government reviewers were not reflected in approval outcomes. She wrote that, in one project, reviewers identified risks to the endangered wood turtle and lichen habitats that were not addressed by the project owner. In another, reviewers raised wildfire risk concerns that Adair said were not matched by terms and conditions in the government approval.

Adair made 13 recommendations to improve environmental assessment terms and conditions and compliance monitoring after projects are approved. The auditor said the Environment Department agreed with all of the recommendations, including strengthening assessment terms and conditions by adding measurable criteria with clearly defined timelines and requiring staff to record their rationale when reviewer input is not incorporated.

The audit also said the department should verify the qualifications of external consultants involved in the assessments. Adair added that concerns raised in the report were previously flagged in 2017, and that those issues had been addressed by the time of a 2020 follow-up, but not anymore.

During a news conference Tuesday, Adair said, “It’s concerning when we hear things from government reviewers that they’re being muzzled, or they're being discouraged from putting their concerns forward. That was kind of a common theme as we carried out our work, so it's very concerning.”

Environment Minister Tim Halman defended the province’s approvals in an emailed statement, writing that “decisions are made with rigor, and grounded in a lens of science, facts and evidence.” In the same statement, he said reviewers do “incredible and important work” to ensure informed decisions, while not directly addressing questions about the alleged muzzling of government reviewers.

The audit said Nova Scotia’s environmental assessment process is generally consistent with other provinces. Adair said the province is relying on onshore wind energy to meet renewable energy targets by 2030, and noted there are more than 300 commercial wind turbines operating in the province.

As of 2025, Adair said the turbines generated about 17 per cent of Nova Scotia’s total electricity production, with wind farms owned by Nova Scotia Power, community organizations and independent energy producers.

NDP environment critic Lisa Lachance said the audit is “deeply concerning” and told reporters people who are experts in government are “not being allowed to do their jobs,” adding that Nova Scotians can’t trust the assessment process as a result.

← More stories