In a Nov. 19 opinion, energy policy chair Barry Penner says B.C.’s next financial review should extend to BC Hydro and the government choices driving future electricity demand.
The Story
In an opinion published Nov. 19, Barry Penner, K.C., chair of the Energy Futures Institute, argued that B.C.’s incoming government should extend the promised independent review of the province’s finances to BC Hydro and to the policies that are expected to increase future electricity demand.
Penner pointed to B.C.’s rising public debt and costs, saying the provincial deficit is approaching $14 billion and interest costs have been increasing. He also cited BC Hydro’s financial position, noting the utility’s net debt reached $35.4 billion by this summer, including an increase of more than $1 billion in just three months.
The opinion also highlights BC Hydro’s recent spending on electricity imports, stating the utility spent $2.1 billion importing electricity over the previous three years. Penner said improved water conditions and the completion of the $16-billion Site C dam—now known as the John Horgan Dam and Generating Station—have increased domestic electricity generation, but that the past three years still show the cost of meeting demand through imported power.
Penner’s opinion refers to a decision from the B.C. Utilities Commission (BCUC) on Oct. 27, when it accepted BC Hydro’s long-term resource plan. He said the commission confirmed the need to acquire another 5,000 gigawatt-hours of clean electricity annually by 2034 (roughly equivalent to the output of one Site C dam) and 400 megawatts of dependable generating capacity by 2030. The opinion also says the BCUC supported retaining two existing natural gas-fired plants that the outgoing government had previously planned to shut down.
According to Penner, the BCUC also said decisions about whether electricity should be supplied to LNG projects and data centres are a matter of government policy rather than something its review of BC Hydro’s plan was intended to address. He said that is an issue the new government must confront.
Penner further cited a Nov. 12 report from S&P Global Energy, which he said projects that under an accelerated LNG development scenario, electrification could require approximately 3,100 megawatts of additional capacity by 2050 and major transmission expansion in B.C. The opinion says the projection assumes large new LNG terminals would use electricity for their liquefaction processes and frames questions about where additional power would come from and who would pay for it.
The opinion also points to B.C.’s efforts to allocate electricity capacity for AI and conventional data centres. Penner said the outgoing NDP government proposed making up to 400 megawatts available over two years, and that BC Hydro received 15 applications seeking almost 800 megawatts, with final selections originally promised by September but delayed by the snap election.
Penner said government mandates would add to electricity demand. He cited B.C.’s Zero Carbon Step Code constraining natural gas heating in new buildings, and said new equipment standards would shift more home and office heating to the electricity grid—particularly on the coldest days when demand peaks. The opinion also references BC Hydro research showing that Lower Mainland homes with dual-fuel heating systems (heat pumps backed by natural gas) have approximately 75 per cent lower winter peak electricity demand than homes relying entirely on electric heat pumps.
In the opinion, Penner also says BC Hydro’s latest plan indicated the defeated NDP government’s building electrification policies could add 10,300 gigawatt-hours of annual electricity demand by 2050, which he equated to roughly two more Site C dams.
On vehicle mandates, Penner said the previous government announced in April it would hold the 2027 zero-emission vehicle (ZEV) compliance requirement at approximately 26 per cent, but the published regulation specifies 42.6 per cent for 2027 (and 26.3 per cent for 2026). He said the incoming government should promptly clarify the legally applicable requirements.
The opinion says actual ZEV sales are falling short of B.C.’s targets, citing Statistics Canada data that ZEVs—including plug-in hybrids—represented 18.7 per cent of new vehicle registrations in B.C. in the second quarter of 2026. Penner also noted that the federal government already regulates vehicles across Canada, and said separate provincial quotas would add monitoring and enforcement bureaucracy.
Finally, Penner wrote that manufacturers face penalties of $20,000 for each vehicle sold beyond the permitted number of non-ZEVs. He concluded that the independent review should identify how much electricity BC Hydro needs, why the demand exists, who benefits, who pays, and whether other uses are being displaced.
Penner signed the opinion as a former B.C. environment minister, attorney general and minister of Aboriginal relations and reconciliation.
← More stories