Vancouver Television · National

Child protection advocates urge MPs to advance Bill C-34 after warnings on suicide, trafficking

Child protection advocates urge MPs to advance Bill C-34 after warnings on suicide, trafficking

A pediatrician and child protection advocates told MPs that Bill C-34 would address harms to children from social media and AI chatbots.

The Story

A pediatrician and child protection advocates urged federal lawmakers to move ahead with the Liberal government’s digital safety bill after warning that online harms are affecting children’s mental health and safety.

Charlotte Moore Hepburn of Toronto’s Hospital for Sick Children said the “unfettered, unchecked introduction of social media and AI chatbots into the lives of children” without enforced safety standards or meaningful platform accountability amounts to “the largest fully unregulated clinical trial manipulating the human brain in the history of civilization.” Hepburn made the comments during her appearance Thursday before the House of Commons heritage committee, which is studying Bill C-34.

Hepburn said the bill’s proposed measures include a duty to act responsibly on companies behind social media platforms and AI chatbots, and a requirement that social media platforms block access for children under 16, with the possibility of exemptions if safeguards are in place.

In describing the impact on children, Hepburn told MPs she has seen cases in which relentless online bullying preceded a near-fatal overdose, and she said social media also provides instructions for self-harm.

Hepburn added that her hospital has had to set up a dedicated clinic for child victims of sexual trafficking.

Lianna McDonald, executive director of the Canadian Centre for Child Protection, said reports to the organization’s tip line have risen by 300 per cent since 2020, most involving online platforms, and she said she has “never seen it this bad.” McDonald cited a case involving a youth in Nova Scotia who, she said, was sexually extorted; she said that after he told his parents, the extortion attempt continued and “In the morning, they found him. He’d taken his own life.”

McDonald said a minimum age for social media access would not be a “panacea,” but she called it “a meaningful harm reduction measure,” while acknowledging that details of how verification and the scope of platforms would work are still undecided.

Conservative MP Andrew Lawton pressed Hepburn about the bill’s age restriction elements, pointing to a report from the institute where Hepburn is medical director that said age bans can be counterproductive.

Hepburn said the report’s conclusion looked at an age ban “in the absence of the constellation of other services as outlined in C-34,” including a robust regulator, safety-by-design rules, and a regime that would allow children to rejoin platforms once they are safe.

After the heritage committee hears from witnesses and considers amendments, the bill would still need to move through the parliamentary process in both the House and Senate before it can become law, according to the bill’s described path.

← More stories